Reading order
| # | Title | Published | Author | Buy on Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Sweet Murder | 2017 | Tegan Maher | Buy |
| 2 | Cruise Ship Caper | 2019 | Tegan Maher | Buy |
| 3 | Murder to the Max | 2017 | Tegan Maher | Buy |
| 4 | Bubble, Bubble, Here Comes Trouble | 2017 | Tegan Maher | Buy |
| 5 | Murder So Magical | 2018 | Tegan Maher | Buy |
| 6 | Mayhem and Murder | 2018 | Tegan Maher | Buy |
| 7 | Moonshine Valentine | 2018 | Tegan Maher | Buy |
| 8 | Murder and Marinade | 2018 | Tegan Maher | Buy |
| 9 | Witching for a Miracle | 2018 | Tegan Maher | Buy |
| 10 | Hook, Line, and Murder | 2018 | Tegan Maher | Buy |
| 11 | Murder of the Month | 2018 | Tegan Maher | Buy |
| 12 | Makeovers and Murder (Witches of Keyhole Lake, #8 | 2019 | Tegan Maher | N/A |
| 13 | Southern Fried Murder | 2019 | Tegan Maher | Buy |
| 14 | Murder in the Mansion | 2019 | Tegan Maher | Buy |
| 15 | Mudflaps and Murder | 2020 | Tegan Maher | Buy |
| 16 | Murder without Mercy | 2020 | Tegan Maher | Buy |
| 17 | Murder at Midnight | 2020 | Tegan Maher | Buy |
| 18 | Murder in the Mountains | 2021 | Tegan Maher | Buy |
| 19 | Marriage is Murder | 2021 | Tegan Maher | Buy |
| 20 | Makeovers and Murder | 2019 | Tegan Maher | Buy |
| 21 | Magnolias and Murder | 2023 | Tegan Maher | Buy |
| 22 | Mochas and Murder | 2023 | Tegan Maher | Buy |
| 23 | Memaws and Murder | 2024 | Tegan Maher | Buy |
| 24 | Grace’s Grimoire | 2025 | Tegan Maher | Buy |
| 25 | Motions and Murder | 2025 | Tegan Maher | Buy |
| 26 | Magic and Murder | 2026 | Tegan Maher | Buy |
The Witches of Keyhole Lake is Tegan Maher’s longest and most popular series, with 26 books published between 2017 and 2026. Set in a fictional Southern town, the series follows witches who solve murders and deal with supernatural problems in their small community.
The series has been running for nearly a decade and shows no signs of stopping. Each book features a new mystery while building on the relationships and magical world of Keyhole Lake. The murder-themed titles (Sweet Murder, Southern Fried Murder, Magnolias and Murder) give the series a consistent, playful identity.