Reading order
| # | Title | Published | Author | Buy on Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Happily Ever Amish | 2022 | Shelley Shepard Gray | Buy |
| 2 | Once Upon a Buggy | 2023 | Shelley Shepard Gray | Buy |
| 3 | An Amish Cinderella | 2023 | Shelley Shepard Gray | Buy |
The Amish of Apple Creek series, published in 2022 and 2023, puts a fairy tale spin on Amish romance. The titles themselves hint at the approach: Happily Ever Amish, Once Upon a Buggy, and An Amish Cinderella each borrow from classic story structures while staying grounded in the realities of Amish life.
Gray has fun with the fairy tale framing without making it feel forced. The stories work as straightforward Amish romances, but readers who catch the nods to classic tales will find an extra layer of enjoyment.