Taming the Cowboy's Heart books in order

Taming the Cowboys Heart by Cynthia Hickey is a three-book Western romance series about strong-willed cowboy heroes who resist love until the right women gentle their guarded hearts.

Reading order

# Title Published Author Buy on Amazon
1 Warming Stone Cold Lodge 2017 Cynthia Hickey Buy
2 The Reluctant Cowgirl 2017 Cynthia Hickey Buy
3 I’d Rather Kiss My Horse 2018 Cynthia Hickey Buy

Taming the Cowboys Heart presents three Western romances centered on the classic trope of rough cowboys who resist romance until they meet women who break through their defenses. The “taming” metaphor suggests wild hearts that need gentling, with the heroines bringing emotional civilization to men more comfortable with horses and cattle than feelings.

The series balances traditional Western masculinity with the emotional growth required for real relationships, showing that strong men can be vulnerable and that accepting love is its own form of courage. Christian faith helps guide the cowboys toward recognizing that partnership and commitment align with rather than threaten their masculine identity.


Frequently Asked Questions

How many books are in the Taming the Cowboy's Heart series?

There are 3 books in the Taming the Cowboy’s Heart series, published between 2017 and 2018.

What is the first book in the Taming the Cowboy's Heart series?

The first book in the Taming the Cowboy’s Heart series is Warming Stone Cold Lodge, published in 2017.

What makes these cowboys need taming?

Taming the Cowboys Heart features rugged, independent cowboy heroes who have hardened their hearts against romance or commitment, with each book showing how love softens their resistance and teaches them that vulnerability and partnership don’t diminish their strength.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. We may receive commissions for purchases made through links on this site.

Privacy Policy