Reading order
| # | Title | Published | Author | Buy on Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Blessings in Disguise | 2015 | Amy Lillard | N/A |
| 2 | Peace Like a River | 2015 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 3 | Blessing in Disguise | 2015 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 4 | Where Hope Dwells | 2015 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 5 | The Buggy Before the Horse | 2015 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 6 | A Season of Secrets | 2015 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 7 | O Little Town of Sugarcreek | 2015 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 8 | Off the Beaten Path | 2015 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 9 | Simply Vanished | 2016 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 10 | Stranger Things Have Happened | 2016 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 11 | No Time for Trouble | 2016 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 12 | A Stitch in Time | 2016 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 13 | Shoo, FLY, Shoo | 2016 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 14 | Home Sweet Sugarcreek | 2016 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 15 | When There’s a Will | 2016 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 16 | In a Jam | 2016 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 17 | All Abuzz at the Honey Bee | 2016 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 18 | Mason Jar Mayhem | 2016 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 19 | Earthly Treasures | 2016 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 20 | A Tempting Taste Of Mystery | 2017 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 21 | Digging Up Doubts | 2017 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 22 | A Play On Words | 2017 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 23 | In the Fullness of Time | 2017 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 24 | Horse Sense and Sensibility | 2017 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 25 | Secrets Plain and Simple | 2018 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 26 | When Angels Whisper | 2022 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 27 | Hark! The Herald Angel Falls | 2024 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 28 | Till We Meet Again | 2018 | Amy Lillard | N/A |
Amy Lillard’s Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries is a long-running fiction series with 28 books. It started in 2015 with Blessings in Disguise and continued steadily through 2018, with two additional entries arriving later in 2022 and 2024. The bulk of the series appeared across 2015 and 2016, when Amy Lillard published at a rapid pace with titles like Peace Like a River, Where Hope Dwells, A Season of Secrets, and Mason Jar Mayhem.
The series is set in the Amish community of Sugarcreek, and the mystery titles often play on familiar sayings and local flavor. Books like The Buggy Before the Horse, Shoo, FLY, Shoo, and Horse Sense and Sensibility give a sense of the lighthearted wordplay woven through the series. Readers should start with Blessings in Disguise and work through in order, as recurring characters and ongoing storylines connect the books from one to the next.