Reading order
| # | Title | Published | Author | Buy on Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Peace Like a River | 2015 | Olivia Newport | Buy |
| 2 | Blessing in Disguise | 2015 | Olivia Newport | Buy |
| 3 | Where Hope Dwells | 2015 | Olivia Newport | Buy |
| 4 | The Buggy Before the Horse | 2015 | Olivia Newport | Buy |
| 5 | A Season of Secrets | 2015 | Olivia Newport | Buy |
| 6 | O Little Town of Sugarcreek | 2015 | Olivia Newport | Buy |
| 7 | Off the Beaten Path | 2015 | Olivia Newport | Buy |
| 8 | Simply Vanished | 2016 | Olivia Newport | Buy |
| 9 | Stranger Things Have Happened | 2016 | Olivia Newport | Buy |
| 10 | No Time for Trouble | 2016 | Olivia Newport | Buy |
| 11 | A Stitch in Time | 2016 | Olivia Newport | Buy |
| 12 | Shoo, FLY, Shoo | 2016 | Olivia Newport | Buy |
| 13 | Home Sweet Sugarcreek | 2016 | Olivia Newport | Buy |
| 14 | When There’s a Will | 2016 | Olivia Newport | Buy |
| 15 | In a Jam | 2016 | Olivia Newport | Buy |
| 16 | All Abuzz at the Honey Bee | 2016 | Olivia Newport | Buy |
| 17 | Mason Jar Mayhem | 2016 | Olivia Newport | Buy |
| 18 | Earthly Treasures | 2016 | Olivia Newport | Buy |
| 19 | A Tempting Taste Of Mystery | 2017 | Olivia Newport | Buy |
| 20 | Digging Up Doubts | 2017 | Olivia Newport | Buy |
| 21 | A Play On Words | 2017 | Olivia Newport | Buy |
| 22 | In the Fullness of Time | 2017 | Olivia Newport | Buy |
| 23 | Horse Sense and Sensibility | 2017 | Olivia Newport | Buy |
| 24 | Secrets Plain and Simple | 2018 | Olivia Newport | Buy |
| 25 | When Angels Whisper | 2022 | Olivia Newport | Buy |
| 26 | Hark! The Herald Angel Falls | 2024 | Olivia Newport | Buy |
The Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries is a cozy mystery series set in the Amish community of Sugarcreek, Ohio. Peace Like a River (2015) opens the series, which ran for twenty-six books through Hark! The Herald Angel Falls (2024).
Each book presents a new mystery set against the backdrop of Amish life, with recurring characters and a strong sense of place. The series includes seasonal stories and covers nearly a decade of small-town puzzles.