Reading order
| # | Title | Published | Author | Buy on Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | The Time It Snowed in Puerto Rico | 2009 | Sarah McCoy | Buy |
| 2 | The Baker’s Daughter | 2012 | Sarah McCoy | Buy |
| 3 | The Mapmaker’s Children | 2014 | Sarah McCoy | Buy |
| 4 | Marilla of Green Gables | 2018 | Sarah McCoy | Buy |
| 5 | Mustique Island | 2022 | Sarah McCoy | Buy |
| 6 | Whatever Happened to Lori Lovely? | 2025 | Sarah McCoy | Buy |
Sarah McCoy’s standalone novels each explore a different historical setting and set of characters. The Time It Snowed in Puerto Rico (2009) was her debut, and subsequent novels have taken readers to wartime Germany, Prince Edward Island, and other locations.
Her most widely known book is Marilla of Green Gables, which reimagines the backstory of a beloved literary character. Each novel stands independently, united by McCoy’s interest in how personal histories are shaped by the larger forces of culture and time.