Reading order
| # | Title | Published | Author | Buy on Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Sarah’s Deception | 2014 | Cynthia Hickey | Buy |
| 2 | Sarah’s Welcome | 2014 | Cynthia Hickey | Buy |
| 3 | Sarah’s Predicament | 2014 | Cynthia Hickey | Buy |
| 4 | Sarah’s Decision | 2014 | Cynthia Hickey | Buy |
| 5 | Plain Sanctuary | 2014 | Cynthia Hickey | Buy |
Plain Sanctuary explores the theme of finding refuge in Amish communities, where outsiders or those in danger discover safety in the simple, faith-centered lifestyle. The five books follow different characters who enter the plain world, whether fleeing threats, seeking spiritual renewal, or investigating mysteries, and find themselves drawn to both the community and romantic interests within it.
The series balances the peaceful, traditional setting of Amish life with the tension created by danger intruding on that sanctuary. Romance often develops between outsiders and Amish community members, or among those seeking refuge together, creating emotional stakes alongside the suspenseful plots. Christian faith is central to both the setting and the characters’ journeys toward safety, healing, and love.