Reading order
| # | Title | Published | Author | Buy on Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Marry Me, Millie | 2021 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 2 | The Amish Matchmaker | 2022 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 3 | One More Time for Joy | 2023 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 4 | When Hattie Finds Love | 2023 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
Amy Lillard’s Paradise Valley series is a four-book fiction collection published between 2021 and 2023. The series opens with Marry Me, Millie and continues through The Amish Matchmaker, One More Time for Joy, and When Hattie Finds Love. The character-driven titles suggest each book centers on a different woman’s story within the Paradise Valley setting.
Reading in publication order is the best approach here. The books came out at a steady pace of about one per year, and the recurring setting means characters from earlier entries are likely to appear in later ones. Start with Marry Me, Millie to get the full experience of the series from the beginning.