Gay Amish Romance books in order

The Gay Amish Romance series by Keira Andrews follows two young Amish men who fall in love during Rumspringa and must choose between their community and each other.

Reading order

# Title Published Author Buy on Amazon
1 A Forbidden Rumspringa 2014 Keira Andrews Buy
2 A Clean Break 2015 Keira Andrews Buy
3 A Way Home 2015 Keira Andrews Buy
4 Wish Come True 2015 Keira Andrews N/A
5 A Very English Christmas 2015 Keira Andrews Buy

The Gay Amish Romance series is one of Keira Andrews’ most popular works. A Forbidden Rumspringa (2014) follows two young Amish men who discover their feelings for each other during Rumspringa, the period when Amish teenagers are allowed to experience the outside world before committing to the church.

The series continues through A Clean Break, A Way Home, and Wish Come True (all 2015), tracing the difficult choices the couple faces as they weigh love against faith, family, and everything they have ever known. The books handle the cultural setting with care while telling an emotionally gripping love story.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many books are in the Gay Amish Romance series?

There are five books in the Gay Amish Romance series, published between 2014 and 2015.

What is the first book in the Gay Amish Romance series?

The first book in the Gay Amish Romance series is A Forbidden Rumspringa, published in 2014.

Is the Gay Amish Romance series respectful of Amish culture?

Keira Andrews has spoken about researching Amish life and culture extensively for the series. The books portray the Amish community with nuance, showing both the appeal of the close-knit lifestyle and the real conflicts that arise when personal identity clashes with community expectations.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. We may receive commissions for purchases made through links on this site.

Privacy Policy