Reading order
| # | Title | Published | Author | Buy on Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Scrooge You! | 2015 | Shannyn Leah | Buy |
| 2 | Love on the Boardwalk | 2019 | Shannyn Leah | Buy |
| 3 | September Breeze | 2019 | Shannyn Leah | Buy |
| 4 | Jewel of the Bay | 2019 | Shannyn Leah | Buy |
| 5 | Must Love Maybe | 2019 | Shannyn Leah | Buy |
| 6 | Treasure of my Heart | 2019 | Shannyn Leah | Buy |
| 7 | Hers to Choose | 2019 | Shannyn Leah | Buy |
| 8 | Save It for a Rainy Day | 2020 | Shannyn Leah | Buy |
| 9 | Celebration on Seafoam Street | 2020 | Shannyn Leah | Buy |
| 10 | Control the Burn | 2021 | Shannyn Leah | Buy |
| 11 | Haunting on Seafoam Street | 2021 | Shannyn Leah | Buy |
| 12 | Unmarried with Children | 2021 | Shannyn Leah | Buy |
| 13 | Anchor his Soul | 2021 | Shannyn Leah | Buy |
| 14 | Fight the Burn: A Steamy Forbidden Love Romance | 2022 | Shannyn Leah | Buy |
| 15 | Everyone’s a Critic | 2022 | Shannyn Leah | Buy |
| 16 | Her Wild Ride | 2023 | Shannyn Leah | Buy |
| 17 | Playing Doctor | 2024 | Shannyn Leah | Buy |
Cinnamon Bay started as a collaborative project with Shannyn Leah as one of its co-founders, built around a fictional coastal town where a Matchmaking Trio and a mythical ingredient called Love Spice conspire to bring couples together. The shared world format means different authors write their own stories set in the same town, with overlapping characters and locations giving the series its connective tissue.
Leah’s own contributions to the series run from early installments through the 2020s, including Scrooge You!, Treasure of my Heart, Anchor his Soul, and several others. The series spans seventeen books between 2015 and 2024, covering holidays, enemies-to-lovers plots, forbidden romance, and beach-town charm. Readers who enjoy small-town romance with a touch of magical match-making will find plenty to explore across the full run.