Reading order
| # | Title | Published | Author | Buy on Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Brodie’s Bride | 2013 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 2 | Can’t Buy Me Love | 2013 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 3 | All You Need Is Love | 2013 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 4 | The Trouble with Millionaires | 2015 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 5 | Love Potion Me, Baby | 2015 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 6 | Blame It on Texas | 2017 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 7 | Ten Reasons Not to Date a Cop | 2017 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 8 | Forget Me Not, Baby | 2022 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 9 | The Amish Christmas Promise | 2023 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 10 | A Million to One | 2023 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 11 | The Amish Bachelor’s Promise | 2025 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 12 | The Secrets We Keep | 2025 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
| 13 | The Amish Nanny’s Secret | 2025 | Amy Lillard | Buy |
Amy Lillard’s standalone novels span over a decade, from Brodie’s Bride in 2013 to The Amish Nanny’s Secret in 2025. The thirteen titles cover a wide range within romance and fiction: early entries like Can’t Buy Me Love, All You Need Is Love, and Love Potion Me, Baby have a playful, contemporary romance feel, while later books such as The Amish Christmas Promise and The Amish Bachelor’s Promise reflect Lillard’s shift toward Amish-set stories.
The publication history shows distinct clusters. Three novels arrived in 2013, two in 2015, two in 2017, and then a five-year gap before Forget Me Not, Baby in 2022. The pace picked up again with two books in 2023 and three scheduled for 2025. That pattern mirrors the career of a working author who balances standalones with her many ongoing series.
Since these are all independent stories, readers can start anywhere. The mix of contemporary romance titles (Blame It on Texas, Ten Reasons Not to Date a Cop) and Amish fiction (The Secrets We Keep, The Amish Nanny’s Secret) means there is variety here for different tastes, all under one author’s name.