Reading order
| # | Title | Published | Author | Buy on Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Hearse and Buggy | 2012 | Laura Bradford / Elizabeth Lynn Casey | Buy |
| 2 | Assaulted Pretzel | 2013 | Laura Bradford / Elizabeth Lynn Casey | Buy |
| 3 | Shunned and Dangerous | 2014 | Laura Bradford / Elizabeth Lynn Casey | Buy |
| 4 | Suspendered Sentence | 2015 | Laura Bradford / Elizabeth Lynn Casey | Buy |
| 5 | A Christmas Mourning | 2015 | Laura Bradford / Elizabeth Lynn Casey | Buy |
| 6 | A Churn for the Worse | 2016 | Laura Bradford / Elizabeth Lynn Casey | Buy |
| 7 | Plain as Day | 2018 | Laura Bradford / Elizabeth Lynn Casey | Buy |
| 8 | Just Plain Murder | 2018 | Laura Bradford / Elizabeth Lynn Casey | Buy |
| 9 | A Killer Carol | 2019 | Laura Bradford / Elizabeth Lynn Casey | Buy |
The Amish Mysteries series brings the cozy mystery formula to an Amish setting. The protagonist, Claire Weatherly, runs a bed-and-breakfast near an Amish community and finds herself drawn into murder investigations that touch both the Amish and English worlds. Hearse and Buggy (2012) introduces the setup, and the series continued for nine books through A Killer Carol (2019).
The titles lean into Amish wordplay: Assaulted Pretzel, Shunned and Dangerous, Suspendered Sentence, A Churn for the Worse. The series combines the gentle pace of cozy mystery with the cultural contrast between Amish and modern American life.