Reading order
| # | Title | Published | Author | Buy on Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Secrets of the Amish Diary | TBD | Rachael O. Phillips | N/A |
| 2 | Hearse and Buggy | 2012 | Rachael O. Phillips | Buy |
| 3 | Assaulted Pretzel | 2013 | Rachael O. Phillips | Buy |
| 4 | Shunned and Dangerous | 2014 | Rachael O. Phillips | Buy |
| 5 | Suspendered Sentence | 2015 | Rachael O. Phillips | Buy |
| 6 | A Christmas Mourning | 2015 | Rachael O. Phillips | Buy |
| 7 | A Churn for the Worse | 2016 | Rachael O. Phillips | Buy |
| 8 | Plain as Day | 2018 | Rachael O. Phillips | Buy |
| 9 | Just Plain Murder | 2018 | Rachael O. Phillips | Buy |
| 10 | A Killer Carol | 2019 | Rachael O. Phillips | Buy |
The Amish Mysteries series by Rachael O. Phillips combines cozy mystery storytelling with the world of Amish communities. Starting with Secrets of the Amish Diary, the series runs ten books through A Killer Carol (2019), each bringing a new mystery to solve amid buggies, pretzels, and pastoral settings.
The series is notable for its playful titles that blend Amish life with crime fiction wordplay. Hearse and Buggy, Assaulted Pretzel, Shunned and Dangerous, and Suspendered Sentence all give a sense of the lighthearted tone. Holiday entries like A Christmas Mourning and A Killer Carol round out the collection.