Reading order
| # | Title | Published | Author | Buy on Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Secrets of the Amish Diary | 2016 | Sandra Orchard | Buy |
| 2 | Plain Deception | 2016 | Sandra Orchard | Buy |
| 3 | Simple Lies | 2016 | Sandra Orchard | Buy |
| 4 | Murder Simply Played | 2016 | Sandra Orchard | N/A |
| 5 | To Love and to Vanish | 2016 | Sandra Orchard | Buy |
| 6 | Law & Old Order | 2016 | Sandra Orchard | Buy |
| 7 | A Silent Betrayal | 2016 | Sandra Orchard | N/A |
| 8 | Humble Pies and White Lies | 2016 | Sandra Orchard | Buy |
| 9 | Deceptive Hearts | 2016 | Sandra Orchard | Buy |
| 10 | Stolen Past | 2016 | Sandra Orchard | Buy |
| 11 | Homespun Homicide | 2016 | Sandra Orchard | Buy |
| 12 | Broken Melody | 2016 | Sandra Orchard | Buy |
| 13 | Horse and Burglary | 2017 | Sandra Orchard | Buy |
| 14 | A Fatal Harvest | 2017 | Sandra Orchard | N/A |
| 15 | A Simple Deduction | 2017 | Sandra Orchard | Buy |
| 16 | The Hound and the Fury | 2017 | Sandra Orchard | Buy |
| 17 | Unhappy Returns | 2017 | Sandra Orchard | Buy |
| 18 | Skating the Law | 2017 | Sandra Orchard | Buy |
| 19 | Book Clubbed | 2018 | Sandra Orchard | Buy |
| 20 | Farmed Robbery | 2018 | Sandra Orchard | Buy |
| 21 | Scene of the Chime | 2018 | Sandra Orchard | Buy |
| 22 | Amish and Old Lace | 2018 | Sandra Orchard | N/A |
| 23 | To Honor and Betray | 2018 | Sandra Orchard | Buy |
The Amish Inn Mysteries is a cozy mystery series published by Annies Fiction, set in an inn located in Amish country. The series follows the innkeeper as she encounters a steady stream of crimes and secrets in her peaceful community. Titles like Plain Deception, Simple Lies, and Murder Simply Played give a sense of the series’ tone, mixing Amish-country atmosphere with cozy whodunit plotting.
This is a multi-author series, with Sandra Orchard as one of several contributing writers. The 23 books were published between 2016 and 2018 as part of Annies Fiction’s subscription book club. Each installment features a new mystery while maintaining the same setting and core cast. Readers who enjoy Amish-set fiction combined with gentle mystery will find this series a natural fit, though it leans more toward the cozy mystery side than traditional Amish fiction.