A Magic Island Paranormal Cozy Mystery books in order

A Magic Island is a seven-book paranormal cozy mystery series by Emery Belle, set on an enchanted island where the protagonist navigates witchcraft, spells, and murder mysteries.

Reading order

# Title Published Author Buy on Amazon
1 Beached & Bewitched 2018 Emery Belle Buy
2 Oceans & Potions 2018 Emery Belle Buy
3 Fang Ten 2019 Emery Belle Buy
4 Beyond the Seer 2019 Emery Belle Buy
5 Toil & Trouble 2019 Emery Belle N/A
6 Fool’s Gold 2020 Emery Belle N/A
7 Witch’s Brew 2020 Emery Belle N/A

The A Magic Island Paranormal Cozy Mystery series begins with Beached & Bewitched (2018), which introduces the island and its unusual residents. The protagonist is new to the community and has to find her footing among people who take magic for granted, while also dealing with the first of several murders that will need solving before the series ends.

The seven books follow a steady rhythm: a mystery surfaces, the island community gets involved, and magic plays a role in how the case unfolds. The titles keep a playful, punny quality throughout (Fang Ten, Beyond the Seer, Witch’s Brew), which matches the series’ tone. These are not dark or gruesome books; the emphasis is on atmosphere, character relationships, and the fun of a setting where ordinary rules do not apply.

Emery Belle published all seven books between 2018 and 2020. The series should be read in order, as recurring characters and relationships develop from book to book. Start with Beached & Bewitched.


Frequently Asked Questions

How many books are in the A Magic Island Paranormal Cozy Mystery series?

There are seven books in the A Magic Island Paranormal Cozy Mystery series, published between 2018 and 2020.

What is the first book in the A Magic Island Paranormal Cozy Mystery series?

The first book in the A Magic Island Paranormal Cozy Mystery series is Beached & Bewitched, published in 2018.

What is the main setting of the A Magic Island series?

The series is set on a magical island community where residents include witches and other supernatural figures. The island setting keeps the cast contained, which is common in cozy mysteries, and the paranormal elements are woven into everyday island life rather than treated as exceptional.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. We may receive commissions for purchases made through links on this site.

Privacy Policy